The New Kid assists Big Gay Al in a scavenger hunt to locate all of his missing cats. While Big Gay Al does not physically appear in the game, he can be added as Facebook friend by answering the cell phone in Mr. Video Games South Park: The Stick of Truth The two appear to be close friends, as Al invited Marc over to play sad music while he packed away his things from his scouting career in " Cripple Fight", and afterward Marc played uplifting music when Al requested. When he hosted the USO Show in South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut, Al was accompanied by a pianist named Marc who played the backing music for his new song " I'm Super" while Al sang and performed elaborate choreography involving dancers, costumes, and more. They often appear together at large gatherings, such as in " The City Part of Town" to see the Whole Foods representative's arrival and in " Bike Parade" holding a barbecue during the bike parade and watching the kids. Al and Slave, finding agreement with this, help the boys to change the definition of "faggot" from a gay person to an annoying Harley rider, with Al presiding over meetings in town and brandishing a rifle against the Harley riders. Slave and Big Gay Al are the first to see the boys' attempts at getting rid of the local Harley Riders, by writing "Fags Get Out!" Initially they are pained and horrified by the sign, until realizing that the boys did not mean anything disparaging against gays, but were instead using the term "Fag" in regards to the Harley Riders, stating "You can be gay, and not a fag". Slave are married by Father Maxi in a major ceremony, with Stan, Kyle, Wendy and Randy Marsh among those in attendance. Slave back when her effort fail, Al and Mr. Garrison swears she will stop gay marriage from becoming legal so that she can have Mr. Slave back, is enraged by the news and more so when Slave announces their engagement. Garrison sometime after the other two men had broken up over the latter's sex change operation, and that Slave and Al had moved in together. In " Follow That Egg!", it was revealed that Big Gay Al had started up a relationship with Mr. He appears to be very compassionate about things he loves, saving homosexual animals in " Big Gay Al's Big Gay Boat Ride", being in the scouts since age nine in " Cripple Fight", and etc. He is a stereotypical homosexual: upbeat, happy, optimistic, and flamboyant. To see images of Big Gay Al, visit Big Gay Al/Gallery.
In the future timeline set in South Park: Post Covid, his hair has faded, and his skin is no longer tanned. Big Gay Al is thick set and has brown hair, eyelashes, a mustache, and very red lips. He wears a pink Hawaiian shirt open at the top, exposing his left nipple, a blue neckerchief, and brown corduroy trousers. He rejected this, saying he knows the Scout leaders are still good men, and since the scouts are a private club, they should have the right to exclude people if they choose to, just as he has the right to express himself as a gay man. The boys, however, didn't like their new Scouts Leader, and rallied to get Al back, and Gloria Allred and others forced the Scouts to re-accept him. However, the parents of the children were uneasy about a gay scout leader, and the club fired him. In " Cripple Fight", He later took up the position of scout master of troop 69, since he had been in the scouts since he was nine years old. His singing voice for the song was provided by Trey Parker. He was the co-host and an entertainer at the troops' USO show, in which he performed his own musical number, " I'm Super". He had a minor role in South Park: Bigger, Longer & Uncut, where it was revealed that he is in fact a celebrity. Later on in the episode, his large shelter transforms into a briefcase and flies away, but the various animals remain and are reclaimed by their owners, who had missed them very much. Stan then wanted Sparky back, and Big Gay Al agreed to return him, but only after explaining homosexuality to Stan. He temporarily adopted Sparky, Stan Marsh's homosexual dog, who had run away from home after Stan had gotten upset with him. In his first appearance in " Big Gay Al's Big Gay Boat Ride", he ran an animal sanctuary reserved for gay animals who had been rejected by homophobic pet owners.